Never buy a Sony BMG music CD again

Sony BMG apparently has some new DRM on audio CDs which installs a kernel mode rootkit on Windows machines.

Who bought the music? Whose computer is it? Sony wants control not only the music but the machine you are using to play the music? Also not only is Sony using a rootkit, but apparently it is coded in a very sloppy manner which could cause machine level stability issues.

. . .It’s never safe to unload a driver that patches the system call table since some thread might be just about to execute the first instruction of a hooked function when the driver unloads; if that happens the thread will jump into invalid memory. There’s no way for a driver to protect against this occurrence, but the Aries driver supports unloading and tries to keep track of whether any threads are executing its code. The programmer failed to consider the race condition I’ve described.

I am not sure quite how to put this - lets see - *fuck you* Sony.

And a sidenote, it was SysInternals peeps that discovered this great new Sony technology, if you do use Windows regularly (and own Sony music CDs or not) you will want SysInternals great util RootkitRevealer.

Comments

RE: Never buy a Sony BMG music CD again

I just noticed Ars has a story about this too.

This seems like a perfect time to stop using Sony products and consuming Sony content. The company has a long track record of doing whatever it can to protect its products. As Hannibal pointed out,

"The company is obsessed with digital piracy, and the PC interfaces for their digital devices are invariably buggy, intrusive, slow, and almost seem to be designed to make the user just give up and buy Sony physical media."

In this case, even buying the Sony physical media is a spectacularly bad idea given what it will do to your system. If it's already on there, good luck getting it off.

RE: Never buy a Sony BMG music CD again

You know, I used to love my Clie, but I had nothing but problems trying to get it to play music like it was supposed to. Songs that I riddped would have a 75% chance of playing and a 25% chance of a copy protection problem.

Sad to see a company so capable doing so much wrong.

RE: Never buy a Sony BMG music CD again

I agree Mr Phil, I used to really like Sony, especially hardware wise for home electonics. Lately though it seems every move they make is insanely anti consumer and I just dont buy anything from them anymore, not a CD, not a CD player, so on.

Also I think that Ars article is very good but the statement "doing whatever it can to protect its products" is a bit misleading or easily misconstrued in that context. Certainly no on is saying Sony has no right to protect their products, they do (even if doing that is really dumb when your customers dont want it) but they DONT have a right to do anything to the device I use to PLAY the media, thats the issue. Sony owns the songs sure, but they dont own the record player and all interfaces therein.

RE: Never buy a Sony BMG music CD again

RE: Never buy a Sony BMG music CD again

Too little. An attitude like "we want to allay any unecessary concerns" shows they still dont understand a large part of the issue. Also "the antipiracy software itself will not be removed, only exposed to view." They are going to "patch" the rootkit so its not a rootkit, remains to be seen, but they still are installing crap on your computer for an audio CD. No thanks.

RE: Never buy a Sony BMG music CD again

I didn't say that it was, merely that they reacted quickly.

To be honest, I've not bought a CD from a brick and mortar in years. I'm an iTunes/JHymn fan.

Wait, I lied. I lost my "Princess Bride" soundtrack and nothing online sold it, so I did order that from Amazon the other week. Fortunately, it was old enough that drm was just a mispelled word back then.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.