StuP posted in a comment that he was unhappy with the readability of white on blue in the stories. While I don't have the same problem, I have found myself squinting at the black on blue comments. I have generally, though, gotten favorable reviews of the colors from people I have talked to face to face about the new look.
Anyway:
1. Do you like the current color scheme?
2. What are your criticisms if any?
Comments
RE: POLL: TOTSP Colors
What... No poll button? Get to work and put some code in.
I personally like the colors... Would like a purple based one also.
RE: POLL: TOTSP Colors
Current colors are great.
RE: POLL: TOTSP Colors
I have to admit - I hae a dual monitor display and it's almost unreadable on the second monitor (the blue is lighter and grayer). I would prefer an alternate skin thats a little more high contrast.
RE: POLL: TOTSP Colors
f the anti-bush movement.
Oh. Sorry, that got away from me.
I don't care for the comment colors nor size, really. On my crappy monitor at work, I gotta squint like an old man to see anything. 'Course I'm rapidly becoming an old man, soo.....
A couple of other things would be to *not* default 'anonymous' into the Name field of the 'add comment' area and to lengthen and widen out this box here.
RE: POLL: TOTSP Colors
ok, ok, i get the idear, i will get some alternate styles together ASAP and make that a user pref or something.
RE: POLL: TOTSP Colors
Hey... glad to have had an impact here :)
1. No.
2. Well...
The white on deep blue (headers) is great. The lighter blue background is much harder to read unless I bump the font-size up to much larger than I need to for *any* other site. (Love the Ctrl+ScrollWheel feature :)
Also, the text sizes are quite small cf other sites. (The google ads on the RHS and this comments box are about 200% the size of the comments... so I suspect that your CSS is FUBAR).
As a general rule, there is *no* colour that both white and black text will be legible on. And to top that off, blues are the worst colours to pick as it is blue that the eye is least sensitive to.
(And all this is on my swanky 15.4" LCD on my new laptop... so it's not even a shagged out CRT that hasn't got any contrast left that I'm having troubles with!)
Ah... just found one of the issues here... you've broken one of the "nice-CSS" rules:
body {
font-size: 8pt;
}
Please use percentages!!! That way, things will be relative to the settings that I have on my browser (i.e. I may normally have 10pt while my grandma may normally have 14pt, but you force us both to use 8pt). Using pt is slightly less unforgivable than using px for font sizes in a stylesheet, but it's still bad form.
Here's a W3C tip about it...:
http://www.w3.org/QA/Tips/font-size
And while I'm providing such feedback, can you make this damned textarea box bigger? (5 lines * 30 columns isn't very big to try and write and review comments in!
Thanks!!!
RE: POLL: TOTSP Colors
Wow, all valid points, didnt realize I had fubared things this badly. I even ran these colors by quite a few people before I launched them (obviously none of us, myself especially, being very graphically inclined).
Thanks for all the tips, implementing them now.
RE: POLL: TOTSP Colors
the reason i didnt make the comment box larger also was that it sort of dominated the page originally and i shrunk it. i admit its a pain functionally though and will make it larger.
RE: POLL: TOTSP Colors
OK, I made font sizes percentages and other spacings px (rather than pt) and made this comment box larger.
As soon as I get a chance I will first try to come up with some new colors for a default style (to replace this "azure" release) and then get the user prefs thing in place so that folks can style at least the colors however they want.
Thanks for all the feedback, its obviously needed to make things better and its greatly appreciated.
RE: POLL: TOTSP Colors
Hey I just noticed - Cooper started this thread asking about changes and Atrox actually responded and did all the work. So fess up, either you're one in the same person or Atrox has ben 0wned by Cooper
RE: POLL: TOTSP Colors
He's my bitch :P
Actually Im playing with the stylesheets on my machine too, but I don't have access to the prod server to update them.
RE: POLL: TOTSP Colors
Im just looking at making the background blue a little more blue so the white stands out and making the background on the comments white.
RE: POLL: TOTSP Colors
Also really like that atrox added the total comments on the story list next to each story.
RE: POLL: TOTSP Colors
Just uppin' the text size made it more readable to me. And personally, I think that atrox and Nathan are the same person. Gives "me, myself, and I" all new meaning.
;)
RE: POLL: TOTSP Colors
The real question is who is anonymous.
RE: POLL: TOTSP Colors
I am Sparticus!
RE: POLL: TOTSP Colors
Hey, the change to % not pt has made a huge difference... Ctrl+MouseWheel not needed any more. Yay!
Black on blue is still suboptimal, but it's all getting better. (even if you made the background-color on the comment boxes (threadViewTable-body) a lighter blue then (something like #ccccff) then that would solve that problem.
Perhaps see if you can do the textarea size using CSS (can't remember how well supported that is, sorry) then you could make it wide without it pushing the boundary of the page for some people.
Good work, guys... both (or one!) of you.
RE: POLL: TOTSP Colors
actually we are different people, coop and I that is (and the Nathan crack was just a low blow man, ouch). its just that coop is an idea man, he is smarter than I am no doubt, but he is above getting his hands dirty to actually do something, the burden falls to the little people.
RE: POLL: TOTSP Colors
oh, and i will get a lighter blue and a few other css tweaks checked in today.
RE: POLL: TOTSP Colors
So whats the verdict now? I went darker blue everywhere white font is used and a lighter blue everywhere black font is used (almost too light I think, but I couldnt find a good one really).
I definitely like the darker blue with white but not sure about the comments now, they are more readable but not sure how it affects the overall cosmetic feel of the page.
anyway, thanks to all for the great feedback. special props to Stup for all the explicit tips and such, much appreciated.
RE: POLL: TOTSP Colors
i like it. great change.
RE: POLL: TOTSP Colors
It's workin for me. 2 Thumbs up
RE: POLL: TOTSP Colors
"making it nice for the people"
RE: POLL: TOTSP Colors
Liking it lots. Much more legible, and I think the aethetics of the page are good. Might have to pinch this colour scheme for the next site I design *smirk*
No worries about the help; happy to been able to complain and help at the same time :)